HomeNFL NewsJoe Burrow's MVP Odds Keep Climbing, But Cincinnati's Rebuilt Defense Is the...

Joe Burrow’s MVP Odds Keep Climbing, But Cincinnati’s Rebuilt Defense Is the Real Story

Bettors have pushed Joe Burrow’s MVP odds toward the middle of the pack for 2026. Quarterback Joe Burrow has the receiving corps to justify that confidence. The bigger question in Cincinnati: did the Bengals actually fix a defense that just had the worst season in franchise history?

The Situation

The Bengals finished 6-11 in 2025, their worst mark since 2020. They missed the playoffs for a third straight year. Head coach Zac Taylor still hasn’t reached the postseason level owner Mike Brown wants, but the team brought him back anyway. Brown also retained director of player personnel Duke Tobin, believing that last year was more about injuries than a broken roster.

That injury mattered. Burrow needed surgery for a turf toe injury in Week 2. The recovery kept him out for months and limited him to eight games. Backup quarterback Joe Flacco took over under center, and Cincinnati’s playoff hopes faded well before December.

Even with Burrow sidelined for a chunk of the year, the offense wasn’t the problem. The defense allowed 492 points, the most in a single season in Bengals history. Cincinnati finished 30th in the league in points allowed and 31st in total yards. That’s the backdrop for every Joe Burrow MVP odds conversation this summer. The passing game looks elite. The defense keeps dragging it down, though.

The Evidence

Cincinnati was active this offseason. The Bengals traded the 10th overall pick to the New York Giants for defensive tackle Dexter Lawrence. It marked the first time in franchise history they’ve dealt a top-ten selection for a veteran. They also signed defensive tackle Jonathan Allen to a two-year, $28 million deal after Washington released the two-time Pro Bowler. Allen adds size and pass-rush juice to an interior line that opposing offenses manhandled a year ago.

The secondary got an even bigger upgrade. Safety Bryan Cook signed a three-year, $40.25 million contract this spring. He ranked sixth among qualified safeties in pass coverage grade with the Kansas City Chiefs last season, allowing fewer yards per catch than almost any safety in the league. Cincinnati’s defensive backs missed tackles at an alarming rate in 2025. Cook should solve exactly that problem.

Burrow still has wide receiver Ja’Marr Chase and wide receiver Tee Higgins on the other side of the ball. That duo arguably forms the best one-two receiving punch in the NFL. Sportsbooks have priced Burrow as a favorite in multiple passing categories heading into the year. Pair that passing attack with real defensive investment, and it’s clear why Burrow’s MVP price has tightened since last season, when the defense gave him no margin for error.

The Counter-Argument

None of this guarantees a turnaround. Defensive coordinator Al Golden returns for a second season despite presiding over the worst defensive year in franchise history. Continuity only pays off if the scheme actually fits the new personnel. New additions like Lawrence, Allen and Cook also need time to gel. Overhauls built through free agency and trades rarely click immediately, especially up front.

There’s also the injury risk around Burrow himself. A quarterback coming off toe surgery sits one hard landing away from another lost season. Cincinnati’s Super Bowl window narrows every year the roster doesn’t convert a stacked offense into playoff wins. Bettors backing Burrow for MVP are, in effect, also betting he stays upright behind an offensive line that hasn’t always protected him well.

The Verdict

The roster looks better than it did a year ago. Cincinnati doesn’t need a top-10 defense to make the playoffs. It just needs to stop being historically awful. A run-stuffer like Lawrence, a veteran presence like Allen, and a sure tackler like Cook should move that needle, even in a transition year. Pair a merely average defense with an offense built around Burrow, Chase, and Higgins, and Cincinnati looks like a wild card team again.

The counter-argument still matters. If Golden’s unit keeps bleeding points in October, Taylor’s seat heats up fast. No amount of Joe Burrow MVP odds buzz can save a season the defense has already decided.

Cincinnati opens the year at home. How the new-look front seven holds up in that game will say more about this team’s ceiling than any offseason odds board.

Elias Vance
Elias Vance
Elias Vance is a veteran sports analyst with over 12 years of experience specializing in advanced performance metrics for the NFL and NBA.

LEAVE A REPLY

Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here

- Advertisment -

Most Popular

Recent Comments