The New York Giants’ promising start took a sudden turn during Week 2 against the Los Angeles Rams. Second-year quarterback Jaxson Dart left the contest on the opening drive following a hit by pass rushers Byron Young and Josaiah Stewart. Further medical testing confirmed structural damage across his knee, specifically involving his MCL, PCL, and meniscus.
Head coach John Harbaugh confirmed Dart will undergo surgery and land on injured reserve, ruling him out for the remainder of the regular season. While Harbaugh left open a small chance of a return if New York qualifies for the postseason and learns how do the NFL playoffs work firsthand this winter, the realistic expectation is that Dart will not take another snap until spring OTAs in 2027.
With Dart sidelined, general manager Joe Schoen and the coaching staff face an urgent test: recalibrate the playbook around veteran Jameis Winston while reinforcing an alarmingly thin quarterback room.
Shifting from Dual-Threat RPOs to a Heavy Play-Action Scheme
Dart gave offensive coordinator Greg Roman and senior offensive assistant Matt Nagy a versatile weapon. In the Week 1 win over Dallas, Dart dissected the defense with 230 passing yards, three scores, and 54 yards on the ground, creating horizontal stress through designed runs, read-options, and run-pass options (RPOs).
Winston offers plenty of arm talent and a fearlessness when testing tight windows, but he is a traditional pocket passer. His arrival under center removes designed quarterback runs from the game plan.
To keep the offense productive, the staff must adapt toward concepts favored by Brian Callahan and Sean McVay:
- Under-Center Play-Action: Lining up in heavier personnel groups to establish the run, forcing safeties into the box, and creating isolated deep shots for Malik Nabers, Isaiah Likely, and Darnell Mooney.
- Leaning on Ground Support: Relying on tailbacks Cam Skattebo and Najee Harris to control tempo, manage the clock, and protect Winston from obvious third-and-long situations.
Evaluating the Depth Chart: The DeVito and Garoppolo Possibilities
Winston holds the starting job, but New York needs reliable depth beyond practice-squad passer Jake Haener. Finding stability at the most important positions in football gives Big Blue clear paths to explore:
| Target | Current Status | Acquisition Cost | System & Roster Fit |
|---|---|---|---|
| Tommy DeVito | New England Patriots (Backup) | Low (Late-round future draft pick) | Knows East Rutherford well, proved he can handle local pressure during his 3-3 rookie run, and accepts a backup role. |
| Jimmy Garoppolo | Free Agent | None (Cap space only) | Extensive experience in Shanahan- and McVay-style schemes, veteran poise, and playoff starting experience. |
| Jake Haener | Giants Practice Squad | Internal promotion | Cost-effective in-house solution, but lacks regular-season starting snaps. |
The DeVito angle carries strong emotional weight across North Jersey. During his 2023 rookie stretch, “Tommy Cutlets” delivered an unforgettable spark, completing 65.3 percent of his attempts for 1,358 yards, eight touchdowns, and three interceptions. Now sitting behind rookie franchise starter Drake Maye in New England, DeVito could serve as a culturally popular, drama-free depth piece if the Patriots accept a future late-round pick.
Meanwhile, league insiders note that veteran Jimmy Garoppolo remains unsigned on the open market. Garoppolo has stayed in playing shape and offers a steady, veteran floor without requiring draft assets, making him an equally logical target if Schoen decides against trading future capital.
The Long-Term QB Discussion
Dart’s health setback has also fueled wider television debates. On FS1’s First Things First, analyst Chris Broussard suggested that if New York finishes in the top tier of the draft order, front offices must examine elite prospects like Arch Manning or Dante Moore. Broussard noted that team decision-makers must evaluate how does the NFL draft work when top-five capital aligns with durability concerns over a 14-game sample size.
Still, the Giants organization has historically shown strong patience with first-round signal-callers, and Harbaugh took the job largely because he believes in Dart’s ability to develop into a premier starter.
For 2026, the long-term draft debate remains secondary. The immediate priority is adapting the playbook to Winston’s arm and finding dependable insurance behind him before the season slips away.
