Drew Brees says quarterback Josh Allen’s Super Bowl chances still run through one obstacle: Chiefs quarterback Patrick Mahomes. The Hall of Fame quarterback delivered that assessment on Fox Sports’ Covino & Rich show as Allen and the Buffalo Bills open camp still chasing the one trophy that has eluded them for eight seasons.
What Drew Brees Said
Brees was asked to weigh in on the AFC’s crop of ringless star quarterbacks and started with the Bills’ franchise passer. “I’ll start with Josh Allen. He’s certainly a fan favorite. I’m a giant fan of him. I love the way he plays the game. I love the way he’s evolved,” Brees said on the show. He didn’t stop there.
Brees moved next to Baltimore Ravens quarterback Lamar Jackson and Cincinnati Bengals quarterback Joe Burrow, arguing all three ringless stars are stuck telling the same story. “I was then going to go to Lamar Jackson [and] Joe Burrow. I feel the same way about those guys and what they mean to their teams and franchises. The problem has been they all got to go through Mahomes and the Chiefs,” Brees added. It’s a blunt way to frame three MVP-caliber careers, but the tape backs him up.
Brees reached for a comparison from his own era to make the point land. “It’s just like Peyton had to go through with Brady, right? How many Super Bowls would Peyton Manning go to if it wasn’t for Tom Brady, right? So there’s always those epic battles,” Brees said. Former Colts and Broncos quarterback Peyton Manning won two Super Bowls in his career, but Patriots quarterback Tom Brady’s teams bounced him from the playoffs repeatedly during his prime, a parallel Brees clearly still thinks about. Hall of Fame quarterback Drew Brees knows the feeling from a different angle too, since he never got past this same AFC gauntlet himself in his final playoff runs.
The Background
The numbers support Brees’ framing more than most quarterback rivalries do. Mahomes has beaten Allen in all four of their playoff meetings, with those wins coming in either the AFC Championship Game or the divisional round. Burrow has fared slightly better, beating Mahomes three times across the regular season and postseason, but the Chiefs eliminated Burrow’s Bengals in the AFC Championship Game in January 2023 after Burrow had already knocked Mahomes out of the AFC title game the year before on the way to Super Bowl LVI.
There’s a fresh wrinkle to the rivalry heading into 2026. Mahomes tore his ACL late in the 2025 season, an injury that ended Kansas City’s year early and helped drop the franchise to a losing record for the first time since he took over at quarterback. The Chiefs have been careful with his workload since. That caution led the team to hold Chiefs quarterback Patrick Mahomes out of Kansas City’s preseason finale while he builds toward the regular-season opener.
What It Means for Josh Allen’s Super Bowl Chances
Brees’ Manning-Brady comparison isn’t just nostalgia. Manning and Brady met seven times in the postseason across their careers, and Brady’s teams won the majority of those meetings, part of why Manning finished with two rings instead of a total that better matched his individual dominance. Brees is arguing that Allen, Jackson, and Burrow are living a version of that same story, except the obstacle wears No. 15 in Kansas City instead of No. 12 in New England.
For Buffalo specifically, the stakes carry extra weight. Allen has never lost the AFC title fight to anyone but Mahomes, and the Bills enter 2026 under new head coach Joe Brady after the franchise moved on from Sean McDermott. Quarterback Josh Allen’s shoulder scare last November against the Texans is a reminder that durability matters just as much as talent in this chase.
What Comes Next
Mahomes’ recovery timeline is the variable every AFC contender is watching. If he’s limited or eased in slowly, it cracks open a window that Allen, Jackson, and Burrow haven’t had since before the 2024 season.
Cincinnati Bengals quarterback Joe Burrow is heading into the year knowing a healthy Mahomes means the Bengals need every possible edge just to get back into the AFC title conversation. Buffalo, Baltimore, and Cincinnati will all get their answer in real time once the regular season kicks off, and until Mahomes proves he’s fully himself again, Josh Allen’s Super Bowl chances look as open as they’ve been in years.
